cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Reply

JSS

Ace Contributor
Graeme M Member Since: May 11, 2017
91 of 1,448

I have had a similar expereince, but I don't think that there is anything that you can do as clients are impossible to predict. You may have an excellent relationship with them with great communication, met deadlines and excellent work, but still receive less than 5 stars. The general rule of thumb is alway over deliver on your projects, try to be early on submitting your work and really put in some extra effort into your submissions. This seems to work in most cases, but still does not guarantee anything. 

Active Member
Emilio B Member Since: May 12, 2017
92 of 1,448

I just want to say how dissapointed I am in the Upwork job success score and if some of the Upwork support members will please explain how in the world is this possible.

I had a 94% job success and then I got 5 contracts in the past 3 weeks. Now out of the 5 contracts, 4 of them were with a grade of 5.00 and one was 4.40. And my job success score now has fallen down to 91%?

Please do not tell me that it private feedback is the culprit there is no way that out of all the 5 star contract that they have given me a lower private feedback because clients do not tend to do that. 

I am just 6 weeks away from being top rated and this has now put my top rated status in jeaopardy.

A real shame from Upwork, a real shame.

Community Guru
Petra R Member Since: Aug 3, 2011
93 of 1,448

The comment on the 4.4 star feedback hints at poor private feedback so that contract counts against you for sure.

 

With only 19 ended contracts each contract weighs very heavily (represents over 5% of all your ended contracts) so one bad contract can tank you several percent.

Active Member
g g Member Since: Nov 27, 2017
94 of 1,448

But four 5 star contracts are not taken into consideration to atleast NOT lower my job success score?

Community Guru
Petra R Member Since: Aug 3, 2011
95 of 1,448

@Matej K wrote:

But four 5 star contracts are not taken into consideration to atleast NOT lower my job success score?


Weren’t you called Emilio a post ago?

 

at any rate, percentages are tricky things, it takes far more contracts to make the percentage rise than fall.

 

Think about it this way:

 

say you have 10 red apples. Your red Apple percentage is 100%

Add 9 more red apples and 1 green apple, your red apple percentage falls to 95%

Add another 8 red apples, and 2 green ones, your red apple percentage falls to 90% .... 

 

Now very simplistically (it is more nuanced than this with JSS) exchange red apples for good outcomes and green apples for bad outcomes and you see why one bad job will always hit you harder than a number of good ones will see your JSS rise, and the nearer you get to 100% the more it takes to get a further increase in the % number.

Community Guru
Brian F Member Since: Jun 4, 2013
96 of 1,448

If Upwork was transparent, it would not be tricky at all.  It's tricky because the chose to make it tricky.

Community Guru
Petra R Member Since: Aug 3, 2011
97 of 1,448

@g g wrote:

But four 5 star contracts are not taken into consideration to atleast NOT lower my job success score?


 Well, Emilio, Matej, and now "G G" ....

 

Your JSS is the least of your worries now.... Still having either one of your two (or more??) accounts at the end of this and just a policy violation (instead of a suspension) on your profile is now much more the issue.......

Community Guru
Tiffany S Member Since: Jan 15, 2016
98 of 1,448

@Emilio B wrote:



Please do not tell me that it private feedback is the culprit there is no way that out of all the 5 star contract that they have given me a lower private feedback because clients do not tend to do that. 

 

I don't think that's what impacted your score, since the 4.4 and the private feedback accompanying it probably dropped you down. However, clients very much DO tend to do that--that's exactly why Upwork dropped average star ratings in favor of a system that factors in private feedback. MANY clients are too cowardly to tell the truth in public, or want to avoid the insane harassment that many freelancers openly admit to engaging in if they don't like their feedback. Private feedback allows them to be honest without repercussions.

Community Guru
Brian F Member Since: Jun 4, 2013
99 of 1,448

"Hints at" ... "private feedback"  I feel you.  This is the least transparent ratings system I've ever encountered, and still people joyfully refuse to say the system could be better or more fair, that there is any room for improvement...

Active Member
Aminul I Member Since: Jul 28, 2017
100 of 1,448

I had 92% JSS even last week. By this time I haven't closed any job. I have been with 4 jobs in progress for the last few weeks. But this week the JSS automatically downgraded to 90%! 2% minus without any reason!

Can anybody tell me why it happened? It's very frustrating for me as 90% is the last limit for being top rated. What I should do now?

Thanks.

Aminul

TOP SOLUTION AUTHORS
TOP KUDOED MEMBERS