Mar 1, 2021 06:02:45 PM by Parisa S
a client is asking me to do a quick criminal background check in order to proceed with the project. they are not an official Upwork corp/business account but seem pretty legit. has anyone been asked before? any advice
Mar 1, 2021 07:09:57 PM by Amanda L
Parisa S wrote:a client is asking me to do a quick criminal background check in order to proceed with the project. they are not an official Upwork corp/business account but seem pretty legit. has anyone been asked before? any advice
I have never been asked to do a background check as a freelancer on Upwork. What is the nature of the job they are offering?
Mar 2, 2021 11:46:25 AM Edited Mar 2, 2021 01:37:50 PM by Parisa S
I think what I did not like was they waited until the end to tell me that was a requirement vs upfront so I felt a bit blind-sighted, days back and forth, meetings, and nothing mentioned during that time. I am used to getting the can you sign an NDA even after the project has started sometimes...but suddenly saying you need to go to this third-party site, enter your social and do this quick check was strange. Upwork should add some questions as users post jobs that guide them to add requirements like this into their posting so we see it from the beginning. I also have been asked for references right at the end of the process which is odd.
Mar 2, 2021 12:42:09 PM by Phyllis G
I thought hard about this for a few minutes and could not come up with a legitimate reason a client contracting with me on UW would need to check my background. I could, on the other hand, think of many reasons someone pretending to be an UW client would like to get their slimy hands on my social security number.
That's a BIG nope.
Mar 2, 2021 01:02:36 PM by Jamie F
Parisa S wrote:but suddenly saying you need to go to this third-party site, enter your social and do this quick check was strange.
Smells like a phishing scam to me.
Mar 2, 2021 01:28:58 PM by Wes C
Parisa S wrote:.but suddenly saying you need to go to this third-party site, enter your social and do this quick check was strange.
This is where I'd walk away, if not before.
Mar 2, 2021 08:55:07 PM by Douglas Michael M
Parisa S wrote:...but suddenly saying you need to go to this third-party site, enter your social and do this quick check was strange.
Oh, my. That's not just a red flag, that's flashing red lights, railroad crossing arms, and clanging alarm bells.
Mar 2, 2021 11:32:24 AM by Martina P
Parisa S wrote:a client is asking me to do a quick criminal background check in order to proceed with the project. they are not an official Upwork corp/business account but seem pretty legit. has anyone been asked before? any advice
Nope. But the whole idea of a background check is that the person that is checked is unaware. If you are supposed to provide it, well, Papier ist geduldig, as we say in German. (Paper is patient. I know, it makes no sense.)
I would tell them that they are free to order a background check on you from any company they please.
Mar 2, 2021 11:44:24 AM by Mary W
Martina, in the US you really need the approval of the person being checked. It's a huge privacy issue, although if you know how you can run the court records for a particular court without permission.
OP- the more I think about this, the less I like it. I've actually applied for US Government jobs that didn't require a background check, particularly a criminal one, until I would be provisionally hired.
I would ask the client why they feel they need to check a freelancer's background. It just smells funny to me.
Mar 2, 2021 12:06:36 PM by Martina P
Mary W wrote:Martina, in the US you really need the approval of the person being checked. It's a huge privacy issue, although if you know how you can run the court records for a particular court without permission.
OP- the more I think about this, the less I like it. I've actually applied for US Government jobs that didn't require a background check, particularly a criminal one, until I would be provisionally hired.
I would ask the client why they feel they need to check a freelancer's background. It just smells funny to me.
Oh wow, I did not know that, thank you. All the companies in the US that offer background checks probably talk about something different then, I assume.
Mar 3, 2021 10:05:41 AM by Valeria K
Hi Parisa,
While it's definitely up to you whether you decide to proceed, requesting a criminal background check would not be a violation of Upwork TOS and can be part of the interview process. You may also refer to the section 2.1 of the User Agreement where it states that "Without limitation, Users are solely responsible for: (a) ensuring the accuracy and legality of any User Content; (b) determining the suitability of other Users for a Service Contract (such as any interviews, vetting, background checks, or similar actions); (c) negotiating, agreeing to, and executing any terms or conditions of Service Contracts; (d) performing Freelancer Services; and/or (e) paying for Freelancer Services."
Mar 3, 2021 10:11:47 AM by Petra R
There are very legitimate businesses that do background checks. I had a background check for a huge ($100k+) contract with an Enterprise client, and it was through one of those legitimate companies.
I wouldn't do it for a small contract and and I wouldn't do it through some random website.
Mar 3, 2021 10:41:16 AM Edited Mar 4, 2021 07:05:45 AM by Parisa S
Exactly. Yes, I have done it through enterprise too but that whole process way more professional, I just think that newer clients who are not enterprise or Upwork plus clients need better guidance from Upwork when they post jobs, on how to approach this so they do not come across as scammy or waste our time. A simple pop-up asking them do they req a background check or other things.
Mar 4, 2021 04:03:07 AM Edited Mar 4, 2021 04:06:33 AM by Petra R
Parisa S wrote:A simple pop-up asking them do they req a background check or other things.
Considering that barely any clients ever need a background check, showing them a pop-up that asks them if they do just gives clients ideas...
Mar 4, 2021 04:29:57 AM by Irene B
Can you imagine the repercussions when every client sees a poput and goes 'ooooo lookeeee here! let's do a check....'
Mar 4, 2021 05:48:06 AM by Kim F
I was once told I'd need a background check and that it would involve taking a drugs test and my neighbours being interviewed. For writing website copy. I put it down to delusions of grandeur.
Mar 5, 2021 03:51:52 AM by Mikko R
Mar 5, 2021 03:53:44 AM by Mikko R
Mar 5, 2021 04:17:00 AM Edited Mar 5, 2021 04:19:16 AM by Petra R
Mikko wrote:
In addition, Upwork Enterprise Clients who've hired me didn't ask for a criminal background check either.
So, just because it didn't happen to you with one Enterprise client means it doesn't happen to anyone with any Enterprise client?
Mikko R wrote:
It doesn't happen.
It does happen! Of course it happens.
Or are you saying that I'm lying? I can assure that this is not the case and all my colleagues had the same background checks.
So, asking for a criminal record on a freelance site is completely absurd
Again, just because you haven't seen it happen does not make it "completely absurd"
Aug 25, 2023 08:18:11 AM Edited Aug 25, 2023 08:26:51 AM by Adam J
This absolutely could be legitimate. It's really frustraiting to see people categorally calling this a SCAM just because they don't have experience of this. It is nowhere near as black and white as some here have suggested. It absolutely may NOT be a scam.
I speak from a place of experience as someone that manages an IT team for a small company that has managed to gain business from very large US / European corporates. My company works in a sensitive industry that deals with a lot of third party private personal data, and so our direct customers are not the concern, but their customers. As a result our customers have very strict standards due to the exchange of data that occurs between the three parties involved.
Very often these large corporates have pushed for very strict standards on the IT staff employed by my company, irelevent if they are freelancers or direct employees of the company. Here are some clauses of contracts we signed in the last years just to give you an example:
Do you perform background checks for all staff / third party contractors who are entrusted with sensitive information or granted access to sensitive systems?
Are background checks performed for Service Provider Contractors and Subcontractors? And is this at time of hire or anually?
So there you have it, some people who decide to use UpWork to find freelancers are indeed going to ask for background checks. It probably isn't that common because any company with contractual terms to their own customers such as those I have given examples of are probably going to not want to get involved in the hassle of this on upwork. I can imagne that many would prefer to find freelancers through agencies where such things are guaranteed to be handled on their behalf by an agency that pre-vets people. To suggst as @Mikko R did that this is "absured" and categorically a scam is staggering.